Trauma and Memory: Why We Can’t Always Remember or Forget

Trauma has a profound effect on memory, both on how memories are stored and how they are recalled. For many trauma survivors, the relationship with memory can be confusing. Some people experience a fragmented recollection of traumatic events, while others may struggle to remember details altogether. In contrast, some might find that certain aspects of the trauma are persistently haunting. This phenomenon raises many questions: Why do some memories seem to be suppressed, and why do certain events feel like they’re playing on an endless loop?

In this post, I will explore the intricate connection between trauma and memory and why it can be difficult to remember or forget traumatic experiences. I’ll break down the reasons behind memory fragmentation, dissociation, and the myths surrounding repressed memories. Understanding this complex relationship is an essential step toward recognizing the effects trauma has on your mental and emotional well-being.

The Role of the Hippocampus: Memory Formation and Distortion

At the core of our ability to remember experiences lies the hippocampus, a small yet crucial part of the brain responsible for forming and organizing memories. Under normal circumstances, the hippocampus helps process and store memories, placing them into a coherent narrative. However, trauma disrupts this process, often leading to fragmented or distorted memories.

During a traumatic event, the hippocampus can become overwhelmed, making it difficult to record the event in a way that allows for proper recall. Rather than storing a clear, organized memory, the brain might store fragmented pieces—sensory details like sounds, smells, and images—without creating a full context. As a result, trauma survivors may experience flashbacks or intrusive memories that are vivid but disjointed, making it challenging to make sense of the experience.

For instance, a person who survived a car accident may vividly remember the sound of screeching tires or the smell of burnt rubber, but the full sequence of events might remain unclear. This disjointed nature of traumatic memories is one of the key reasons survivors might feel disoriented when recalling the event. In extreme cases, the hippocampus may be unable to fully process the trauma, leading to difficulties with memory retention and recall, even long after the event has passed.

Dissociation: A Coping Mechanism That Impacts Memory

Dissociation is another defence mechanism that can affect memory in the wake of trauma. When an individual experiences extreme stress or fear during a traumatic event, their brain may “shut down” to protect them from overwhelming emotions. This can result in dissociation, where the person feels detached from the event, as if they are watching it from outside their own body.

This disconnection can lead to memory gaps, where the person has difficulty recalling parts of the traumatic event. Dissociation can also cause a sense of emotional numbness, where the person feels emotionally distant from the experience or feels as though the event wasn’t real. In some cases, individuals may dissociate so completely that they lose all memory of the event altogether. This can make it difficult for survivors to process what happened or even accept the reality of the trauma.

The difficulty in remembering a traumatic event due to dissociation is not an indication that the individual is “making it up” or exaggerating their experience. It’s a natural and protective response to overwhelming emotional pain. However, the impact of dissociation on memory can complicate the healing process, as it may prevent the person from fully integrating the event into their life narrative.

Repressed Memories: Debunking the Myth

The concept of repressed memories is often surrounded by controversy. The idea that individuals can completely forget traumatic events and later recover those memories has been the subject of much debate. Repressed memories refer to the idea that a person may unconsciously block out memories of a traumatic event because the emotional pain is too great to bear. This theory suggests that the memory is still present but inaccessible to conscious awareness until it is “uncovered.”

While repressed memories are a real phenomenon, they are not as common or as clear-cut as the term suggests. Most trauma survivors can recall some details of their traumatic experience, even if those memories are fragmented or distorted. Rather than being entirely repressed, traumatic memories may become difficult to access due to the way the brain processes them. In some cases, therapy or specific triggers can help an individual recall these memories, but this process is often slow and can cause significant emotional distress.

It’s important to note that not all traumatic memories are repressed, and the recovery of these memories can sometimes be influenced by the therapy process. In some instances, memories can be inaccurately “recovered,” leading to confusion or false recollections. This highlights the importance of working with trained professionals who specialize in trauma, as they can help guide the recovery process in a safe and therapeutic way.

Flashbacks and Intrusive Memories: Reliving the Trauma

Flashbacks are a hallmark symptom of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), where an individual involuntarily re-experiences the traumatic event as though it is happening again. Unlike regular memories, which are stored with a sense of temporal distance, flashbacks feel immediate and real. A person having a flashback might feel as though they are physically back in the traumatic moment, experiencing all the fear, pain, and anxiety as if it were happening in real time.

Intrusive memories are similar to flashbacks but may not be as vivid or as emotionally intense. These memories may pop up uninvited, often triggered by external stimuli, like a sound, smell, or sight, that reminds the person of the trauma. For example, a person who survived a violent assault may feel anxious every time they walk into a crowded room, even if no actual danger is present. These involuntary memories are distressing and can interfere with daily life, making it difficult to function normally.

The intensity of these memories varies depending on the person and the severity of the trauma. Some individuals might experience these memories occasionally, while others might struggle with them on a daily basis. Working through traumatic memories often requires professional support to help individuals process and integrate the trauma into their broader life narrative.

Trauma and Memory: A Complex Relationship

The relationship between trauma and memory is incredibly complex, influenced by factors like the individual’s emotional state, the nature of the trauma, and their ability to cope. Trauma can leave lasting imprints on both the body and the mind, which can make it difficult to recall, understand, or accept what happened. However, memory is not fixed—it can change over time, and with the right therapeutic interventions, it can be rebuilt and reprocessed.

Therapeutic techniques such as Dialectical Behavioural Therapy (DBT), Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR), and trauma-focused therapies aim to help individuals process traumatic memories in a way that reduces their emotional intensity and allows for better recall and integration. Through these therapies, survivors can begin to make sense of their memories, allowing them to gain control over their emotional responses and start the healing process.

Healing the Wounds of Memory

Trauma affects memory in ways that can be difficult to comprehend. Memories of traumatic events may be fragmented, distorted, or entirely suppressed, leaving survivors feeling lost and disconnected from their own experiences. While understanding the science behind memory and trauma can be empowering, it’s important to approach this knowledge with compassion. Trauma survivors need support, understanding, and professional guidance to help them process their memories and heal from the wounds of the past.

By exploring the relationship between trauma and memory, we gain insight into why some traumatic experiences are so challenging to remember or forget. And more importantly, we recognize that healing is possible. With the right help, survivors can begin to piece together their fragmented memories, find meaning in their experiences, and move toward recovery.

---

Key Takeaways

• Trauma affects how memories are stored and recalled – Survivors may experience fragmented memories, difficulty remembering details, or intrusive recollections that feel impossible to forget.

• The hippocampus plays a crucial role in memory processing – During traumatic events, this part of the brain can become overwhelmed, leading to disjointed or incomplete memories that lack clear context.

• Dissociation can impact memory retention – When individuals dissociate during trauma, they may experience memory gaps, emotional detachment, or even complete memory loss of the event as a coping mechanism.

• Flashbacks and intrusive memories are common in trauma survivors – Certain stimuli can trigger overwhelming recollections, making it feel as if the traumatic event is happening again in real time.